WinSxS folder – WTF?

So, I’ve been using Vista quite happily for a fair while now. All the doomsayers complaining about how it would use so much more resources were wrong – provided your turn off the transparent borders on windows it still runs just the same (it seems to me) as XP. I guess I’ve always said to friends that it’s alright – I wouldn’t pay to upgrade to it (it doesn’t seem to offer much), but if I was buying a new PC, I’d be okay with it. The only problem I had doing just that was with blackhole detection in the new TCP/IP stack, and that was… exotic.

However, I think I’ve just found my first big gripe. Performing standard system maintenance on my desktop, which is used pretty much exclusively as a VM host, I noticed that my primary drive was using 40Gb. That seemed rather high for Vista, Office ’07, SharePoint Designer and Adobe Reader. Naturally, I broke out Treesize:

So, 28% of my drive is being taken up by the winsxs folder. What the hell is that? Well, I Googled – and Vista Club has a good description

In Vista, there isn’t a ‘dllcache’ folder and nor can you find the ‘i386’ folder, where the system caches (like in XP) all it’s source modules. It is this WinSxS folder which stores the shared components of side-by-side applications. These files can be multiple versions of the same assembly or application. Every side-by-side assembly has a unique identity. One of the attributes of the assembly identity is its version.

Okay, but why so big? Well, it carries on…

As mentioned, Windows stores the old dll’s and library components in the WinSxS folder. Now if a newer version of this file is a part of the OS, but a particular application requires a particular older version for running, then the older version from the winsxs folder will be used, leaving the newer version in its present place, for other applications which may require it.

So obviously you cannot delete this directory or move it elsewhere. Nor is it advisable to delete anything here, as such a step could probably make your applications un-workable or even break your system! If you have many applications installed, you can expect to have a jumbo sized winsxs folder.

If you delete components from the WinSxS folder like the manifets or the assemblies, etc, you could be in trouble.

….

Compressing the folder is also a no-no, as it could cause problems during WindowsUpdates or while installing a Hotfix.

Holy crap! It’s a 13Gb directory that I can’t tidy up, delete, move or compress! Who designed that, and were their brains on holiday? I get why they did it – to maintain backward compatibility – but sometimes, maybe it’s just best not to. I mean, VB.NET isn’t backwardly compatible with VB6. Office 2003 and 2007 files are only somewhat compatible. Win 95 wasn’t backwardly compatible with 3.1. The .NET framework 2 wasn’t backwardly compatible with 1.1. And in all those cases, it’s worked out for the better. Please Microsoft, break with backwardly compatibility and get rid of this folder.

Advertisements
WinSxS folder – WTF?

2 thoughts on “WinSxS folder – WTF?

  1. Interesting, but in some ways worse – I now can’t trust my tools for administration :/ That’s nearly as bad! For example, if it isn’t actually using that much space, can I use it?

    For example, can I get my hard disk to more than 100% usage?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.